Top 10 Guaranteed No Smudge Eyeliners

When the temperature rises, your perfect cat eye makeup can quickly become a weird smudge on your lids.

You might spend hours and hours on that precise line, and then, poof, it is gone.

And all thanks to the humidity.

This is why you need the best waterproof eyeliner.

Not wanting to wear waterproof mascara is one thing.

One can surely understand that.

The formula can sometimes be drying and turn crispy.

But a waterproof eyeliner?

That is another thing.

All eyeliners should be waterproof.

Sadly, they are not.

What is the point of perfecting your feline flick if that is going to disappear after your lunch?

So, with that in mind, we present you some of the best options for waterproof eyeliner.

We guarantee there will be no smudge if you use any of these.

1. Tarte Tarteist Clay Paint Liner

We start off with a 100% vegan and waterproof eyeliner.

Why vegan?

Well, because today, everyone is going vegan.

At least that seems to be a general opinion.

You can craft the perfect winged look by using this eyeliner.

The innovative, squeezable eyeliner has a unique blending tip inspired by an artist’s palette.

This eyeliner features cushion slide technology that helps you create silky-smooth texture and wear the pigmented formula for 12 hours.

The tube is portable, you can easily carry with you for a quick fix.

There are no parabens or phthalates in the formula.

The product has been tested by ophthalmologists and dermatologist.

It is also safe for contact lens wearers.

PROS

  • It is very black and long lasting
  • The texture lets you get cat eye makeup easier than a liquid
  • Lets you work with it and apply it smoothly in just one swipe
  • thumbs-up
    Dries up as soon as possible
  • thumbs-up
    Creates dark and clean lines once you get the hang of the brush

CONS

  • You might have a hard time squeezing any product out
  • It does not glide on easily and can create a big mess if you are not experienced with the brush
  • Good for experienced users, but beginners will struggle 
  • thumbs-down
    The product quickly dries up in the tube

2. Kat Von D Tattoo Liner

KAT VON D tattoo liner

This liquid eyeliner definitely lives up to its name.

It is like a temporary tattoo on your eyelids.

The brush and inky formula never streak when applying, or when crying.  

The liquid eyeliner comes with an innovative brush tip for effortless and precise application.

You can use it to achieve eye perfection thanks to its high-pigment and waterproof formula.

The flexible and superfine brush tip glides across the lashline for fluid application, allowing you to create a variety of looks with no hassle.

And unlike traditional felt tip liners, this brush will not fray.

This eyeliner is completely free of animal-derived ingredients, and it has not been tested on animals.

If you want to get a subtle defining line, lightly drag the brush tip across the bash from the inner to the outer corner.

For a thinner line, use less pressure and more pressure for a bolder line.

PROS

  • Very smooth and precise
  • Very easy to make a cat eye using the eyeliner
  • Makes using liquid eyeliner a breeze
  • thumbs-up
    The colors are bold and stay put

CONS

  • The bottle runs out in less than a month
  • It is not black unless you go over it multiple times
  • Doesn’t stay for more than 3 hours

3. PERMA PRECISION Liquid Eyeliner

PERMA PRECISION Liquid Eyeliner

If you are lucky enough to go behind the stages at a runway show, you’ll notice this eyeliner is a common commodity.

Used backstage at many top runway shows, the eyeliner is not expensive enough so the average user can afford it.

The inky and super-black liquid eyeliner is best for someone who is a skilled liner enthusiast.

Beginners will have troubles, as it is too liquid for them.

Pat McGrath is one of the most influential makeup artists in the world, and her impact over the past 20 years is astonishing.

Her visionary looks created for runways, editorials, and advertisements are all made possible thanks to her signature makeup.

And they define beauty trends of the future.

This sensual and waterproof eyeliner deliver elegant precision, and lets you achieve the ultimate eye lift as you line and define.

Lasts for up to 24 hours, and it is completely smudge-proof and suitable for humid climates.

PROS

  • The matte black color is unmatched in the world of eyeliners
  • Very precise
  • Goes on smooth, and lasts through the day
  • thumbs-up
    Good pigmentation

CONS

  • After a while, the precision of the tip is gone, and the very tip is dry
  • While it has a flexible tip, it is not precise enough and ink does not come out of the very top of the tip

4. Blinc Liquid Eyeliner

Blinc Liquid Eyeliner

You want to jump in the pool, or survive an intense workout class, and continue your day with your liner on?

Well, then this is an option that you should consider.

Blinc is the first liquid eyeliner that binds to your lash line with a water-resistant stroke of color.

The revolutionary technology forms a water-resistant layer of color that binds to the lash line, and results in a dramatic look and unparalleled hold.

And when you want to take it off, all you need is warm water and gentle pressure to peel it off effortlessly.

The formula of the liner is designed in a way it protects those with sensitive eyes, contact lens wearers, and people who are active and workout on a regular basis.

PROS

  • Come with an actual bristle brush which makes the application seamless
  • The color is completely opaque
  • You need only one application to get a pure black color
  • thumbs-up
    Does not make your eyes sting or feel heavy after application

CONS

  • Lasts only for a couple of hours before it starts flaking and smudging
  • The brush is full of liner making it hard to use
  • thumbs-down
    Does not go on even, either it is too thin, or too thick
  • thumbs-down
    Can make your eyelashes fall out

5. Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Eyeliner

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Eyeliner

Opaque, and densely-pigmented liner, the gel eyeliner by Bobby Brown is a surefire winner.

Very easy to apply, as it just glides on, the eyeliner will stay on no matter what.

The downside is it is not easy to remove.

The liner is gentle enough for tight-lining, but also strong enough to withstand a tough workout, or a humid environment.

The liner instantly forms a waterproof film that stands up to the humidity, tears, sweat, and anything else.

Formulated with the lowest possible amount of oils and waxes, it is designed for minimal smudging and intense definition.

Apply the liner as close to the lash line as possible, and then line the entire length of the lid using short and even strokes for best results.

PROS

  • Goes on smoothly and easily
  • Stays until you remove it
  • Help keep your regular liner from fading during the day
  • thumbs-up
    Works well for sensitive and hooded eyes

CONS

  • It is a bit drier than most pencil liners
  • The liner has very little product, to begin with
  • thumbs-down
    The color does not last

6. L'Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Eyeliner

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Eyeliner

L’Oreal is usually known as a luxury brand.

But the company is also proof that you do not have to spend a fortune to get a black eyeliner that lasts.

This cheap option, for example, works quickly and lasts for a long time.

The pencil eyeliner glides on easily to help you create rich, and smudge-resistant color that lasts for hours.

Apply along the top and bottom line, starting from the inner corner of the eye and working outward.

If you want a more colorful look, combine with another shade of L’Oreal cosmetics.

The liner is designed only for adults use.

PROS

  • Long lasting and can be applied to the waterline
  • Easy to sharpen with any sharpener
  • Cheap

CONS

  • Once the eyeliner sets, you’ll need an oily makeup remover to get it off
  • Lasts for a short period of time
  • thumbs-down
    Gets very dull and no way to sharpen

7. Too Faced Sketch Marker Liquid Art Eyeliner

Too Faced Sketch Marker Liquid Art Eyeliner

Inspired by Japanese calligraphy pens, this eyeliner allows you to draw a sleek subtle line or geometrical cat eye with such ease.

And the best part about this eyeliner is that it comes in a variety of colors.

The innovative liquid eyeliner has a formula that acts as an artist’s best drawing ink.

This allows you to create paintbrush-like stokes anytime in the day.

The waterproof formula ensures that the eyeliner will not fade or feather.

You can wear a single color or layer together shades to create a double eyeliner.

In terms of safety, the formula does not contain parabens, sulfates, or phthalates, so you can be sure you are getting the real deal.

The product is also gluten-free and cruelty-free.

Most of the shades are vegan-friendly, except for the candy pink and deep lilac.

PROS

  • Very much pigmented 
  • The eyeliner stays on so well
  • Has an easy to use tip
  • thumbs-up
    It is so opaque and will not budge once you put it

CONS

  • Doesn’t wear well when you have eyeshadow on
  • It doesn’t come out right, and when it comes out, it is either too much or too little
  • thumbs-down
    The eyeliner dries out after a few applications

8. IT Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

IT Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

We live in a day and age when the term “IT” is easily associated with high technology.

Well, you can say that this eyeliner is technologically advanced.

The velvety glide of the formula and the super-opaque pigment surely make this liner stand out of the crowd.

The company created the product to give women a skin-loving and anti-aging formula for a luxurious eyeliner that is waterproof and doesn’t tug on the delicate eye area.

Clinically proven to last for more than 8 hours, they are also infused with ingredients that are beneficial for your skin, including vitamin C, vitamin E, hydrolyzed collagen, silk proteins, and much more.

In the same time, there are no sulfates, parabens, or fragrances.

PROS

  • The product is easy to use
  • Great on upper and lower lids
  • Holds up in the heat of the summer

CONS

  • You need to apply a lot of product to create a complete line
  • It runs down after a few hours 
  • thumbs-down
    The color disappears on the corner of your eyes, and you have to re-apply

9. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Modern and sophisticated, this formula was created in 1994 by a celebrity makeup artist.

As such, the company has built a stylishly individual legacy and is known as fashionable.

The innovative formula, in combination with the sleek packaging, is what makes Stila one of the most famous waterproof eyeliners on the market.

The formula does exactly what the name suggest, and that stays on for the whole day.

The liner is easy to apply, waterproof and provides quick-dry precision.

There are no smudges, feathering, or running.

The thin, and marker-like tip is so easy to use, even beginners can use it.

You can use it to create any look, from a thin line, to a bold and dramatic stroke.

PROS

  • It goes on smooth, and it is easy to control the thickness for a variety of looks
  • You can use over eyeshadow, and it will still last
  • Few liners are as black as this one

CONS

  • Can show signs of wear
  • You need to apply multiple coats to achieve even color
  • thumbs-down
    Sticks to eyelashes and make them clump together

10. Wander Beauty Slide Liner Gel Eyeliner

Wander Beauty Slide Liner Gel Eyeliner

Finally, you can have an eyeliner pencil that won’t make you rub and tug your eyelid.

The gel-based formula of this eyeliner glides on the lash line with easy.

What you get is a silky and waterproof, but also pigmented eye pencil that allows you to stylishly line your eyes.

You can go from subtle to sultry, and create a wide variety of looks with the eyeliner.

In addition to helping you create a nice lash line, the eyeliner also moisturizes your lash line.

This multitasking eyeliner is created without parabens or phthalates and has skin-loving ingredients in the formula.

PROS

  • Stays on for many hours
  • Glides on effortlessly
  • No need to go over and over the line

CONS

  • Smudges easily and can give you raccoon eyes
  • Not as pigmented as you would expect
  • thumbs-down
    The pencil is too soft

Leave a Comment